AX Holiday Gift Guide
Gifting secondhand just hits different.
At Amanda's Exchange, we carry plenty of items that are in like-new condition, some unopened or in their original packaging! We've got everything from stocking stuffers to luxury jewelry, and at a fraction of the original price ~ so you can give more for less.
Shopping secondhand reduces waste and gives gently used or unused items a new life, instead of potentially ending up in a landfill. With vintage & consignment, you’ll find the most unique things to give your loved ones.
Here's who we're shopping for this holiday season, and what we've found around the shop that would make a perfect gift.
→![]()
Anthro Auntie
You know her - the one with impeccable taste and a home that always smells like a candle you need to know the name of. Anthro Auntie gravitates toward artful accents, cozy textures, and pieces that feel curated, not cluttered. Her gifts blur the line between decor and conversation starters.
Includes: Flamingo bookends, Flora Candle Co. Midwest Princess Candle, Taper Candle Holder, Pilcro Cardigan
→Vinyl Darling
Equal parts retro and effortlessly cool, Vinyl Darling lives for a good record, can never own too many vintage leather jackets, loves kitschy music-inspired accessories, and knows how to incorporate a band tee into every fit. Her style is rooted in nostalgia, so look for fringe, leather, and perfectly worn tees.
Includes: Kate Spade music pouches, vintage leather jacket, Sondra Roberts fringed purse, lace-up boots, vintage-inspired band tees
→Pilates Pal
Always booked, always glowing, and always in matching athleisure. She loves functional, sleek gifts that support her movement-first lifestyle.
Includes: Core board, sweatproof earbuds, lululemon + elevated athleisure picks
→The It-Girl
This label-loving fashionista gravitates toward designer details, iconic brands, and pieces that feel truly special. She appreciates timeless silhouettes, quality craftsmanship, and the confidence that comes with a recognizable name. For her, gifting is about elegance and intention. While this it-girl may love a Louis, there are a range of prices and styles that you can choose from at Amanda's Exchange. A timeless high-fashion piece doesn't always have to be expensive.
Includes: Burberry handbag, Karine Sultan necklace, Sheepskin coat, Christian Lacroix knit set, Swarovski jewelry set, Gucci lighter case, Louis Vuitton pochette, Valentino boots
→Pet Fanatic
If they have a pet, it will be mentioned within five minutes. Pet Fanatic delights in playful, thoughtful finds that celebrate their furry (or finned) best friends. Bonus points if it’s cozy, crafty, or giftable for both pet and owner.
Includes: Christmas pup puzzle, De Rosa dolphin figurine, cat card, Frenchie sweater, bark-cuterie toys, kitten crochet kit
The Hostess
She makes entertaining look effortless—whether it’s a holiday gathering or a casual weeknight pour. The Hostess appreciates beautiful, useful pieces that elevate the table, the bar, and the overall experience of having people over.
Includes: Tommy Bahama shooters, magnetic glass cleaner, champagne opener, recycled glass pitcher set, wine bottle holder, gold sequin hurricane, Fizz the Season soap set
The Homebody
She finds joy in staying in. She loves slow mornings spent cooking, quiet afternoons with a puzzle, and evenings centered around the table. The Homebody gravitates toward thoughtful, tactile pieces that celebrate home rituals: well-loved recipes, handcrafted serveware, and small ways to bring the garden indoors.
Includes: Le Creuset recipe book holder, recipe book, vintage garden puzzle, hand-carved serving tray, heirloom herb garden
----------------------------------------------------------
When you shop at Amanda’s Exchange, you’re not just checking off your gift list. You are supporting a local, family-owned small business, giving beautiful pieces a second life, and putting money back into your local economy through consignment. We hope you'll stop in and find some great gifts for your loved ones!